Back Row Questions

What you were afraid to ask.Complex ideas, explained clearly.

A game show host found a loophole and won eight straight

Three doors hide a car and two goats. You pick a door; the host, who knows where the car is, opens one of the other doors to show a goat and offers you the switch.

Play the game yourself

Stay or switch?

You picked door 2. The host opened door 3 to show a goat. You can keep your door or switch to door 1.

What the experiment shows

Switching wins exactly when your first pick was wrong, and that happens 2 times in 3.

This holds for a host who knows where the car is, always opens a door with a goat and always offers the switch. With a host who opens a door without looking, the answer changes.

In 1991 Monty Hall played the game at his dining table with a reporter, and twenty games supported this answer. Then he reread the question: nowhere does it say that the host must offer the switch every time. He began to offer it only when the reporter’s first pick was the car, and won the next eight rounds.

From the video

Each link opens the game as a scene of the video shows it.

The video

Three numbered doors.
The video is in production.

Sources

  1. Steve Selvin, letter to The American Statistician, February 1975.
  2. Marilyn vos Savant, “Ask Marilyn”, Parade, September 9, 1990 and February 17, 1991.
  3. The New York Times, 1991.
All questions